Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Saenger's avatar

Interesting article! One thing that stands out is that he had severe, symptomatic mitral regurgitation with LV enlargement a year prior. He therefore met criteria for valve repair or replacement at that time but for whatever reason chose not to. This is a red flag. Did he have some other medical problems that made him refuse valve intervention? Might these have predisposed him to sudden death? Maybe the change in HRV reflected medication changes related to his other problems, for example.

Parigi's avatar

Swimming gives athletes the biological passport Holmer describes — and the pool is its laboratory.

His decisive point is that the signal is not an abnormal number but a body that has stepped away from its own baseline coherently and durably. Here that was HRV more than halved (179 to 91 ms on the daytime measure), resting heart rate up from 44 to 49, sleep and walking capacity sliding in the same cluster — all unfolding four to six months before the event, in a heart already carrying an enlarged ventricle, valve disease, and an old infarct.

The pool offers one of the closest things to laboratory conditions in sport: same lane, same length, same temperature, no wind or gradient. A swimmer who holds 30 strokes per 50 at 1:15 for two seasons and then needs 34 for the same speed has stepped away from their own baseline in exactly the way this post describes. The pace clock and the stroke count are the passport; the wearable just automates the stamp.

What the training log adds is the other deviation: 69 workouts in 79 days, 20 more than all of 2024, the final one among his hardest. The wearables described the vulnerability; the ride history described the load. The question this leaves open, and it matters beyond this case: in a healthy athlete, does a coherent, durable multi-domain shift ever precede the breakdowns we can still act on — overtraining, injury — or does the passport only ever tell us, postmortem, what the body already knew?

12 more comments...

Ready for more?